Skip to main content

Table 1 Variables of cat-subcat Index i1 involved in the model

From: Critical review of the default values used in the environmental impact assessment of biocidal products applied in livestock production systems

Original value

Description of the variable content

Recommendation

Cattle

 1

Dairy cow

Remain, but include calves for remounting until heifer

 2

Beef cattle

Remain

 3

Veal calves

Remain

 ENV 220 [12]

Calves in igloos

Integrate

Pigs

 4

Sows, in individual pens

Since farrowing also takes place in groups, it is recommended to change the wording to “sows in farrowing units”

 5

Sows in groups

Remain

 6

Fattening pigs

Remain

 

Weaner piglets

Currently missing, suggested to add if not covered by the fattening pigs as a worst-case scenario

Poultry

 7–10

Laying hens in battery cages

This housing system has been permitted throughout the EU since 2012; recommend to shorten to one variable “Laying hens in enriched cages”

 11

Laying hens in free range with litter floor (partly litter floor, partly slatted)

Delete the supplement in brackets since the slatted floor in hen husbandry seems to be outdated

 12

Broilers in free range with litter floor

Remain

 13

Laying hens in free range with grating floor (aviary system)

Change order and list before broilers

 14

Parent broilers in free range with granting floor

Remain

 15

Parent broilers in rearing with granting floor

Remain

 16

Turkeys in free range with litter floor

Remain

 17

Ducks in free range with litter floor

Remain

 18

Geese in free range with litter floor

Remain

 

Quails and ostriches

Should be checked if relevant

 19

Manure storage—wet

Remain

 20

Manure storage—wet

Remain

Other species

 

Horses

Not considered, because of missing data. Relevance of insecticide applications is unclear because of an increase of vector-borne diseases, but there are limited data if prevention is performed via chemical or physical vector elimination [16,17,18,19,20]

 

Goat

Should be checked if relevant

 

Sheep

Should be checked if relevant

 

Rabbit

Integrate the decision of the BPC WG ENV IV 2020 that for rabbits, the default values from animal category 10 should be used; however, the amount of nitrogen produced per animal per day should be replaced by the default value for ducks

ENV 207 [12]

Mink

Integrate

 

Farmed game

No worst-case scenario expected, but should be checked for the sake of completeness

 

Insects

No worst-case scenario expected, but should be checked for the sake of completeness

  1. Variables from the ESD were checked based on the literature research regarding systemic categorization from Haupt et al. [15]