Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 2 Compositional analysis

From: Review of GMO safety assessment studies: glyphosate residues in Roundup Ready crops is an ignored issue

References Year published Authors Author affiliation Crop studied Subject Main finding Relevant co-technology Relevant analysis for herbicide residues
[36] 1996 Padgette et al. Industry GTS 40-3-2 soybean Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide not applied Not relevant
[37] 1996 Nida et al. Industry GT-cotton Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide not applied Not relevant
[45] 1999 Taylor et al. Industry GTS 40-3-2 soybean Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide applied at prescribed rate No analysis
[71] 2000 Sidhu et al. Industry GT-corn Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Unclear No analysis
[44] 2002 Ridley et al. Industry GT-maize NK603 Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide applied at prescribed rate No analysis
[72] 2004 Sidhu et al. Industry GT-corn Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Unclear No analysis
[73] 2004 Obert et al. Industry GT-wheat MON71800 Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide not applied Not relevant
[41] 2005 McCann et al. Industry GTS 40-3-2 soybean Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide applied at prescribed rate No analysis
[43] 2006 McCann et al. Industry GT-alfalfa Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide applied at prescribed rate No analysis
[39] 2007 Harrigan et al. Industry GTS 40-3-2 soybean Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide applied at prescribed rate No analysis
[41] 2007 McCann et al. Industry GT-corn MON88017 Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Unclear No analysis
[40] 2008 Lundry et al. Industry GT-soybean MON89788 Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide applied at prescribed rate No analysis
[74] 2010 Berman et al. Industry GT-soybean MON89788 Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide not applied No analysis
[30] 2014 Bøhn et al. Public (university) GTS 40-3-2 soybean Compositional analysis Significant differences found Material from farm-fields: Glyphosate herbicides applied at realistic representative rate Pesticide analysis performed and reported
[75] 2014 Delaney et al. Industry GT-canola DP-Ø73496-4 Compositional analysis Substantial equivalence assumed Glyphosate herbicide applied at prescribed rate No analysis
  1. 15 Published studies comparing compositional quality of glyphosate-tolerant crop varieties with unmodified conventional comparators