Skip to main content

Table 5 Risk assessment and RQ comparison for the approach by EFSA [14] and AMiRA

From: An efficient and pragmatic approach for regulatory aquatic mixture risk assessment of pesticides

Species

Risk according to EFSA [14]

Risk according to AMiRA

Fish

Acceptable, FOCUS step 3

FOCUS step 3:

RQa.s. = 0.8269 < 1

(based on single a.s. risk assessment)

Acceptable, FOCUS step 4 (5 m spray buffer)

FOCUS step 3:

RQmix = 1.0012 > 1

FOCUS step 4 (5 m):

RQmix = 0.6502 < 1

Daphnids

Acceptable, FOCUS step 4 (10 m spray buffer + 10 m veg. strip)

FOCUS step 4 (10 m + 10 m):

RQa.s. = 0.5857 < 1

(based on single a.s. risk assessment)

Acceptable, FOCUS step 4 (10 m spray buffer + 10 m veg. strip)

FOCUS step 4 (10 m + 10 m):

RQmix = 0.5887 < 1

Algae

Not acceptable, FOCUS step 4 (all buffer mitigations)

FOCUS step 4 (all mitig.):

RQmix = 5.9583 > 1a

(based on measured mixture toxicity)

Not acceptable, FOCUS step 4 (all buffer mitigations)

FOCUS step 4 (all mitig.):

RQmix = 4.5831 > 1a

Lemna

Acceptable, FOCUS step 4 (20 m spray buffer + 20 m veg. strip)

FOCUS step 4 (10 m + 10 m):

RQmix = 1.0379 > 1

FOCUS step 4 (20 m + 20 m):

RQmix = 0.5438 < 1

(based on measured mixture toxicity)

Acceptable, FOCUS step 4 (10 m spray buffer + 10 m veg. strip)

FOCUS step 4 (10 m + 10 m):

RQmix = 0.5693 < 1

  1. aPlease note, that necessarily all RQmix > 2 (in case of two active substances in the mixture) consist of at least one single substance RQ > 1 leading to not acceptable risk even for a single substance risk assessment