Skip to main content

Table 4 Mentioned uncertainties in selected review papers

From: Communication about scientific uncertainty: how scientists and science journalists deal with uncertainties in nanoparticle research

Uncertainties

Specification (quantity)

Measurement uncertainties

No adequate analytical methods (5)

Conflicting results

Toxicity studies (2); variability in size, shape, crystallinity, and coatings (2); low amount of data (1); effect of DOM on stability (1); size effect on transport in porous media (1); modeled data (1)

Method uncertainty

No standardized methods and reference materials (6); different/poor characterization (2); risk assessment (2)

Lack of data

Fate (8) and behavior (7) in environmental systems and many specified mechanisms (9); interactions with natural components and contaminants and their effects (5); impact of released nanomaterials on the environment/ecosystems (4); effects of coatings or organic matter on behavior and effects (3); correlation of ENM properties with respect to similar effects (2); different special issues related to fate and effects (8)

Transferability to environment

Toxicity test (3)

Transferability to other nanoparticles

Variability in size, shape, crystallinity, and coatings (2)

Applicability of models

DLVO and filtration theories (3); conventional ecotoxicity tests (3); size dependence of dissolution (2)

Knowledge gap

Quantitative data on environmental concentration (4); form, route, and mass of released nanomaterials (3); behavior at environmentally relevant concentrations and forms (1); production volumes and types (1); fate of embedded nanomaterials (1); surface structure, characteristics, and energetics (1)

  1. DLVO Derjaguin, Landau, Verwey, and Overbeek theory.